The question of whether a hotdog is a sandwich has been the subject of much debate and controversy over the years. Some people argue that a hotdog is a type of sandwich, while others believe that it is a unique food item that should not be classified as a sandwich. In this article, we will explore the various arguments on both sides of the debate and attempt to arrive at a conclusion.
To begin with, we must first define what we mean by the term “sandwich.” According to Merriam-Webster, a sandwich is “two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between.” This definition would seem to suggest that a hotdog is not a sandwich, as it is typically served on a single, long roll rather than two slices of bread or a split roll.
However, some people argue that the definition of a sandwich should be broadened to include any food item that consists of two pieces of bread (or a bread-like item) with filling in between. Under this expanded definition, a hotdog would qualify as a sandwich, as the hotdog itself can be seen as a type of filling between two pieces of bread (the long roll).
Those who argue that a hotdog is a type of sandwich often point to the similarities between a hotdog and other sandwich-like foods, such as a submarine sandwich or a hoagie. Like a hotdog, these foods consist of a long roll filled with meat, cheese, and other toppings. Proponents of this argument also note that many hotdog stands and restaurants list hotdogs under the “sandwiches” section of their menus, further suggesting that a hotdog is a type of sandwich.
However, those who believe that a hotdog is not a sandwich often argue that a hotdog is a unique food item that should not be classified under any other category. They point out that a hotdog is typically made with a specific type of sausage (usually a frankfurter) that is specially designed for use in hotdogs. The hotdog sausage is often served with condiments such as ketchup, mustard, and relish, which are not typically found in other types of sandwiches.
In addition, some people argue that a hotdog is not a sandwich because of the way it is traditionally served. Unlike most sandwiches, which are usually made to order, hotdogs are often pre-cooked and stored in a warming tray, where they can sit for hours before being served. This means that the bread of a hotdog can become soggy and less desirable than the bread of a freshly made sandwich.
Another argument against classifying a hotdog as a sandwich is the fact that hotdogs have their own unique cultural significance. Hotdogs are often associated with specific events and traditions, such as baseball games, Fourth of July celebrations, and county fairs. They are also associated with specific regions of the country, such as Coney Island in New York, where the first hotdog stands were established in the late 19th century. Proponents of this argument believe that classifying a hotdog as a sandwich would diminish its unique cultural significance.
In conclusion, the question of whether a hotdog is a sandwich is a matter of debate and depends on how one chooses to define the term “sandwich.” Under a strict definition of the term, a hotdog would not be considered a sandwich, as it is typically served on a single, long roll rather than two slices of bread or a split roll. However, under a broader definition that includes any food item consisting of two pieces of bread (or a bread-like item) with filling in between, a hotdog could be considered a type of sandwich.
Ultimately, whether or not a hotdog is a sandwich is largely a matter of personal opinion.